Thursday, October 8, 2015

Current Event #3

Microsoft and Google Make Peace in Patent Battles 
http://www.entrepreneur.com/article/251273

"Microsoft Corp and Google Inc have agreed to bury all patent infringement litigation against each other, the companies announced Wednesday, settling 18 cases in the United States and Germany."
When our guest speaker, Clark D. Asay, spoke to us about patent law, he described large corporations building up 'flotillas of patents' as if patents were the nuclear weapons of corporate arms races. It seems that the tech behemoths, Google and Microsoft, have been engaged in the kind of patent warfare that Mr Asay was talking about. This agreement between Google and Microsoft is merely a ceasefire in an ongoing arms race. I think the comparisons to the cold war are appropriate. A patent gives a company the right to sue anyone who infringes on their patent. This is an offensive capability only. In order to defend themselves, it makes sense for large corporations to acquire as many patents as possible, so that if they are ever sued for infringing on another company's patents, they are likely to find that the other company is also infringing on theirs. Because legal battles are incredibly expensive, patent accumulation becomes very much like the 'you nuke us, we nuke you' mentality of the nuclear arms race. Hostilities are so costly to both sides, that it is in everyone's best interest to remain at peace. This is why it isn't surprising that Microsoft and Google managed to come to an agreement to end their legal battles. I'm glad they stopped fighting, even if they only temporarily stop dumping money into our over-sized legal system. No matter the outcome of a legal battle, the lawyers always win. And when the lawyers win, doesn't society lose?

Okay... The lawyer thing was a joke. Kind of...

Thursday, September 24, 2015

Current Event #2

Samsung Told to Stop Copying iPhone

Last Thursday, a federal appeals court ruled that Samsung would have to remove features from its smartphones that mimic similar iphone features such as slide-to-unlock and auto-correct. Although the court ruling sided with Apple in this lawsuit, the court did not lean far to Apple's side. The ruling intentionally did not require Samsung to recall any devices, or remove devices from retail shelves or pay the full amount of damages that Apple was suing for. My feelings are that the court found a narrow balance between two ethical issues. There is the obvious issue of technological theft on the part of Samsung. It's not fair for Samsung to look at the successful iphone and simply copy Apple features into Samsung devices. On the other hand, I personally don't think it's fair for Apple to claim ownership over concepts that are obvious and necessary, such as slide-to-unlock and auto-correct. Sliding a button or tab in order to unlock something is a mechanical feature that has been present in boxes, journals, and doors, for hundreds of years. It is not a new concept. Apple was the first to implement it in a smartphone only because Apple was the first to make a smartphone. Automatically correcting a user's spelling is also a necessary and obvious feature. Unless Samsung literally copied the code implementation of those features, I don't understand how Apple has legs to stand on in this kind of lawsuit. That said, I don't disagree with the ruling because, even though I don't think Apple should own those concepts, I do think that Samsung should be expected to make their own product in a reasonably unique way.

Thursday, September 10, 2015

Current Event #1



"Ashley Madison hackers post millions of customers names..."

A month ago, Ashley Madison, a website that encourages and facilitates infidelity within marriage, was deemed immoral by a group of anonymous hackers who demanded that the site be shut down. The website was not shut down before the hacker's deadline, and so all account information for the website's millions of users was made public. The action taken by the group of hackers is a good example of situational ethics. The website condemned the hackers, saying, "The criminal, or criminals, involved in this act have appointed themselves as the moral judge, juror, and executioner, seeing fit to impose a personal notion of virtue on all of society." I agree with that statement. The hackers acted according to their own definition of 'the greater good'. They ignored rule of law, committing cyber crimes. They trampled individual rights to privacy of personal information. And as a result, they brought down one of the most decadent, depraved entities in our society. If I had been in their position, with the power to ruin a website, which makes money by destroying marriage, with the click of a button, I would be tempted to do exactly the same thing. The problem is, one day I might be ruined by some other ideology imposing their definition of morality on me, and that is exactly why situational ethics doesn't work in our society.