Samsung Told to Stop Copying iPhone
Last Thursday, a federal appeals court ruled that Samsung would have to remove features from its smartphones that mimic similar iphone features such as slide-to-unlock and auto-correct. Although the court ruling sided with Apple in this lawsuit, the court did not lean far to Apple's side. The ruling intentionally did not require Samsung to recall any devices, or remove devices from retail shelves or pay the full amount of damages that Apple was suing for. My feelings are that the court found a narrow balance between two ethical issues. There is the obvious issue of technological theft on the part of Samsung. It's not fair for Samsung to look at the successful iphone and simply copy Apple features into Samsung devices. On the other hand, I personally don't think it's fair for Apple to claim ownership over concepts that are obvious and necessary, such as slide-to-unlock and auto-correct. Sliding a button or tab in order to unlock something is a mechanical feature that has been present in boxes, journals, and doors, for hundreds of years. It is not a new concept. Apple was the first to implement it in a smartphone only because Apple was the first to make a smartphone. Automatically correcting a user's spelling is also a necessary and obvious feature. Unless Samsung literally copied the code implementation of those features, I don't understand how Apple has legs to stand on in this kind of lawsuit. That said, I don't disagree with the ruling because, even though I don't think Apple should own those concepts, I do think that Samsung should be expected to make their own product in a reasonably unique way.